First, we went to IKEA and bought 4 circular mouse pads for $0.99 each. Then, i measured out the diameter of the drum pads (minus the color-ring), used a compass to mark the mouse pads, and used scissors to cut them. As you can see in the closeup image below, the scissors don’t create a completely smooth edge, but we’re going for more function over form here. After cutting the mouse pads, i used double-sided tape to attach them to the drum pads. After testing, we found that the pads are just as sensitive as before, have a better bounce, and are much quieter. I’d say it’s a win-win.

Also, our original bass pedal broke, so we decided to buy a wooden replacement. I can’t seem to find the site again, but there are lots of them on the market now. Overall, we’re very happy with it.